Discourse and Subjectivation Theory Meet Group Discussions: Methodological Considerations for a New Connection

  • Karen Geipel Technische Universität Berlin
Keywords: group discussion, subjectivation, performativity, Judith Butler, poststructuralist subjectivation analysis, discourse analysis, discursive practices, documentary method, discourse research

Abstract

While there is a growing belief that the data used in pedagogical discourse and subjectivation research is made up of statements by speakers from interviews and ethnographic observations, group discussions, represent a type of material in this field that has seldom been taken into account to date. Rather, group discussions have so far been closely linked to the documentary method, which is based on assumptions of the praxeological sociology of knowledge. In contrast, a methodological justification of speaking in group discussions by discourse- and subjectivation-theoretical figures of thought in the German-speaking and international research landscape is still lacking.

In this article, I combine a poststructuralist perspective with group discussions.  I outline methodological assumptions, which have so far established the procedure on the basis of the documentary method, and also carry out central discourse and subjectivation-theoretical premises of a perspective oriented towards the work of Judith BUTLER. By subsequently juxtaposing these approaches , I show to what extent basic assumptions are modified in the course of a post-structuralizing perspective and clarify the potential for poststructuralist discourse and subjectivation analyses. I suggest understanding utterances in group discussions as executions of situated discursive practices and places of processes of subjectivation.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Karen Geipel, Technische Universität Berlin

Karen GEIPEL ist wissenschaftliche Mitarbeiterin am Institut für Erziehungswissenschaft der Technischen Universität Berlin. Arbeitsschwerpunkte: Subjektivierungs-, Diskurs- und Bildungstheorien/-forschung; Differenz und soziale Ungleichheit mit dem Fokus auf gender und race; Zukunftsentwürfe und Übergang Schule/Beruf; Methodologie und Methoden qualitativer Forschung.

Published
2019-05-25
How to Cite
Geipel, K. (2019). Discourse and Subjectivation Theory Meet Group Discussions: Methodological Considerations for a New Connection. Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung / Forum: Qualitative Social Research, 20(2). https://doi.org/10.17169/fqs-20.2.3195